[Skip Navigation]

Research Theme 5 - Cross-Disciplinary

Draw from and contribute to related scholarly disciplines to advance the development of unified knowledge.

Summary

Novel contributions have been made to a number of basic research issues in experimental psychology and cognitive science, including: the relationship between expertise and memory recall; reconstructive remembering of the scientific literature; the relationship between basic and applied research; basic theories in ecological psychology [WEC 95]; cognition in the wild; and, the impact of transparency on the Stroop effect [ALIAS 94]. These contributions have led to publications in several leading journals: Acta Psychologica, American Psychologist, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, Cognition, Ecological Psychology, Memory & Cognition, Perspectives in Science, and Psychological Review.

The effects of external representations on control of complex devices were studied using the DURESS process control simulator [PREA 01]. In addition, cognitive factors contributing to programming errors from patient-controlled analgesia were analysed and the probability of programming errors causing death was estimated [CJA 01]. Future studies should investigate the impact of CEL research on basic theories of coordination phenomena and dynamical systems theory.

Project Listing

The diagram below shows the individual projects that have been performed for this theme, and the relationships between them. Click any project to view its description.

Theme 5: Improving the Fluency of Work - Projects and Relationships ALIAS 94 PREA 01 WEC 95 CJA 01

ALIAS 94 — Improving the Fluency of Work Through Transparent Interface Designs

Dates:

8/94 - 12/95

Participants:

Beverly Harrison, Kim J. Vicente

Collaborators:

Bill Buxton, Gordon Kurtenbach, and Jonathan Shekter, Alias | Wavefront Inc.

The purpose of this research was to improve the fluency of work by introducing "see-through" or semi-transparent user interface objects such as windows, icons, tool palettes, etc. This particular project consisted of controlled laboratory experiments which evaluated divided and focused attention and visual interference issues in semi-transparent interface designs. To this end, a series of experiments were conducted which introduced progressively more realistic task elements taken from the target task domain. The results of these experiments were subsequently used to inform our design choices within selected industrial applications, in particular, 3-D modeling, animation, and painting applications. A case study of transparent user interface objects in a working application was completed. The results of these studies indicate that transparency can improve performance, but that several obstacles must be overcome before this technology can be introduced effectively into commercial products.

Publications:

  • Harrison, B. L., Ishii, H., Vicente, K. J., and Buxton, W. A. S., "Transparent layered user interfaces: An evaluation of a display design to enhance focused and divided attention," Human Factors in Computing Systems: CHI Œ95 Conference Proceedings, pp. 317-324, 1995.
  • Harrison, B. L., Kurtenbach, G., and Vicente, K. J., "An experimental evaluation of transparent user interface tools and information content," Proceedings of the ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology, pp. 81-90, 1995.
  • Harrison, B. L., and Vicente, K. J., "An experimental evaluation of transparent menu usage," Human Factors in Computing Systems: CHI 96 Conference Proceedings, pp. 391-398, 1996.
  • Harrison, B. L., & Vicente, K. J., "A case study of transparent user interfaces in a commercial 3-d modeling and paint application," Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 40th Annual Meeting, pp. 375-379, 1996.
  • CEL 94-07 "Evaluation of a Display Design Space: Transparent Layered User Interfaces" - Beverly L. Harrison, Hiroshi Ishii, Kim J. Vicente, & Bill Buxton.
  • CEL 94-08 "Designing and Evaluating Semi-Transparent 'Silk' User Interface Objects: Supporting Focused and Divided Attention" - Beverly L. Harrison, Shumin Zhai, Kim J. Vicente, & Bill Buxton.
  • CEL 95-07 "An Experimental Evaluation of Transparent Menu Usage" - Beverly L. Harrison & Kim J. Vicente.
  • CEL 96-10 "The Design and Evaluation of Transparent User Interfaces: From Theory to Practice" - Beverly L. Harrison.

CJA 01 — Programming Errors Contribute to Death From Patient-Controlled Analgesia: Report of a Case and Estimate of Probability

Dates:

5/01 - 2/02

Participants:

Kim J. Vicente, Karima Kada-Bekhaled, Gillian Hillel, Andrea Cassano, Beverley A. Orser

The purpose of this project was to identify the factors that threaten patient safety when using patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) and to obtain an evidencebased estimate of the probability of death from user programming errors associated with PCA.

A 19-yr-old woman underwent Cesarean section and delivered a healthy infant. Postoperatively, morphine sulfate (2 mg bolus, lockout interval of six minutes, four-hour limit of 30 mg) was ordered, to be delivered by PCA. A drug cassette containing 1 mg•mL–1 solution of morphine was unavailable, so the nurse used a cassette that contained a more concentrated solution (5 mg•mL–1). 7.5 hr after the PCA was started, the patient was pronounced dead. Blood samples were obtained and autopsy showed a toxic concentration of morphine. The available evidence was consistent with a concentration programming error where morphine 1 mg•mL–1 was entered instead of 5 mg•mL–1. Based on a search of such incidents
in the Food and Drug Administration MDR database and other sources and on a denominator of 22,000,000 provided by the device manufacturer, mortality from user programming errors with this device was estimated to be a low likelihood event (ranging from 1 in 33,000 to 1 in 338,800), but relatively numerous in absolute terms (ranging from 65–667 deaths).

In conclusion, anesthesiologists, nurses, human factors engineers, and device manufacturers can work together to enhance the safety of PCA pumps by redesigning user interfaces, drug cassettes, and hospital operating procedures to minimize programming errors and to enhance their detection before patients are harmed.

Publications:

  • Vicente, K. J., Kada-Bekhaled, K., Hillel, G., Cassano, A., & Orser, B. A., "Programming errors contribute to death from patient-controlled analgesia: Case report and estimate of probability", Canadian Journal of Anesthesia, vol. 50, pp. 328-332, 2003. (with accompanying editorial).

PREA 01 — The Effects of External Representations on the Control of Complex Devices

Dates:

3/01 - 3/02

Participants:

Klaus Christoffersen, Kim J. Vicente

This project involved preparation of a report placing some of the early experimental work on DURESS and DURESS II in the context of the cognitive science literature, specifically the body of work on external representations. The report argues that cognitive scientists have primarily examined effects of the form of external representations, to the exclusion of effects due to their content. The report shows how the AH serves as a tool for modeling content for certain problem domains and illustrates the effects using results from the DURESS/II experiments.

Publications:

  • Christoffersen, K. and Vicente K. J. (In Preparation). The effects of External Representations on the control of complex devices.

WEC 95 — Cognitive Skills Requirements for Authorized Operating Personnel at CANDU Nuclear Generating Stations

Dates:

1/95 - 4/95

Participants:

Catherine M. Burns, Kim J. Vicente

Collaborators:

Randall J. Mumaw and Emilie M. Roth, Westinghouse STC

This project studied the monitoring behaviour of nuclear power plant operators during normal operations at the Pickering Nuclear Generating Station B. Operators were observed during actual operations at the station. As well, a literature review of factors influencing monitoring behaviour was conducted. This study revealed that operators develop a number of creative adaptation strategies to overcome the deficiencies in the existing control room interface, thereby minimizing the demands associated with monitoring and improving performance.

Publications:

  • Vicente, K. J., and Burns, C. M., "Evidence for direct perception from cognition in the wild," Ecological Psychology, vol. 8, pp. 269-280, 1996.
  • Vicente, K. J., Burns, C. M., Mumaw, R. J., & Roth, E. M., "How do operators monitor a nuclear power plant? A field study," Proceedings of the 1996 American Nuclear Society International Topical Meeting on Nuclear Plant Instrumentation, Control and Human-Machine Interface Technologies, pp. 1127-1134, 1996.
  • Roth, E. M., Mumaw, R. J., Vicente, K. J., & Burns, C. M., "Operator monitoring during normal operations: Vigilance or problem-solving? Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 41st Annual Meeting, pp. 158-162, 1997.
  • CEL 95-04 "A Field Study of Operator Cognitive Monitoring at Pickering Nuclear Generating Station-B" - Kim J. Vicente & Catherine M. Burns.